Click for latest discussions

Of Minorities and Their Warlords

Posted by Ben | in History, The wider region | on March 29th, 2007
No tag for this post.

Editor’s Note: What follows is part of a cross-blog survey about minorities in Central Asia. This post, written by Josh Foust, is cross-posted at The Registan.

What is there to say about a country that is, technically, all minorities? For not a single ethnicity in Afghanistan breaches the magical 50% mark to become a true majority, and this has created friction, at the least. Indeed, in one sense, the story of Afghanistan itself is really the story of how its minorities battle for control, power, and the right to live.

By any common definition, the Pashtuns are Afghanistan’s ethnic majority, though they are really only a plurality. And much of Afghanistan’s recent history is the story of their struggle for national and tribal independence. For any discussion of the Pashtun must include a discussion of its tribal divisions, which have played major roles in Afghanistan’s power relationships. As but one example, President Hamid Karzai and the Taliban’s erstwhile leader Mullah Mohammed Omar are members of the Popalzai and Hotak tribes respectively, both centered around Kandahar. The history of conflict between their two tribes reaches back centuries. In 1715, Mirwais Khan Hotak overthrew the local Persian governor of Kandahar, and his son formed an Empire that eventually sacked the ancient capital Isfahan. In 1747, Ahmah Khan Abdali, of Karzai’s Popalzai tribe, was crowned King by a tribal Jirga.

Put differently, much of the fighting in Afghanistan today can be seen as simply the latest stage in a centuries-long conflict between Pashtun tribes.

Reducing Afghanistan to tribal warfare, however, is too simplistic. Abdali (who took the name Durrani and created the royal heritage the Taliban lay claim to in 1994) was named King because the ruler of the Persian Empire, a Turkmen named Nader Shah, was murdered. Today, however, the Turkmen are a comparatively miniscule slice of Afghan ethnicity, whose biggest contributions were to Ahmed Shah Massoud’s Northern Alliance, first against the Soviets, and later against the Taliban.

Massoud is perhaps the gold standard of Afghanistan’s ethnic warriors. A Tajik, the so-called “Lion of the Panjshir,” fiercely defended his home in the Panjshir Valley just north or Kabul for decades, until the Pakistani-funded Taliban drove him north to Feyzabad. Massoud earned a name for himself, and became the pride of Tajiks in Afghanistan, by remaining resolutely independent in his struggle for independence.

He was shunned by the CIA and ISI because he wouldn’t follow their orders, choosing the defense of his home instead of the role of a proxy crusader. He later was forced into virtual exile in the North as the Taliban made their sweep of death across the country. In fact, he was so important, Al-Qaeda assassinated him as part of their September 11 conspiracy—they knew Massoud could rally a U.S.-armed invasion force, and wanted him out of the picture when the towers fell.

Massoud was forced into an uneasy alliance with Abdul Rashid Dostum, an Uzbek warlord known for his ferocity, massacres, and unyielding tactics during the 80s. Though he fought for the Soviet-backed regime, Dostum switched sides in 1992 and turned his back on the communist Najibullah, throwing in his hat with Massoud.

Upon taking Kabul, he initiated a reign of terror that rivaled the worst of the Soviets, turning the city into a pock-marked wasteland. He then switched sides again in 1994, teaming up with Gulbuddin Hekmatyar, a Pashtun from the Kharoti tribe, against the new alliance between Massoud and Berhanuddin Rabbani. Rabbani, also a Tajik, was the President of Afghanistan until his murder in 1996.

In the ensuing fighting, these ethnic warlords turned Kabul into something of a meat grinder, killing tens of thousands of people in just a few years. It was, in every sense of the word, a battle for which race would rule the land—the collection of Tajik warlords, or the alliance of Uzbeks and Pashtuns.

Why go into the history of warlords in Afghanistan? For all intents and purposed, they served as proxies for their ethnic or tribal groups. Each warlord, from the 80’s onward, established his own ethnic enclave, and these would sometimes clash with frightfully bloody consequences. But even beyond the Big Three, as I call them, are a surprisingly large contingent of ethnicities, all of which lay claim to their own barren slice of the country.

Way down south, at the chaotic intersection of Afghanistan, Pakistan, and Iran are the Balochis. They once harbored Mir Aimal Kasi, the man who murdered several employees of the CIA in front of their headquarters in 1993. They chafe at the influence and power of Islamabad, while bemoaning its negligence.

The Hazara live in the middle part of the country, and contributed their own warlord to Afghanistan’s decades of warfare, General Khalili. In stark contrast to the Pashtuns and Tajiks and Turkmen, they are Shia Muslims, which led to some tragic interactions with the Taliban, who considered them apostates.

There are more, of course, including a surprisingly large number of Hindus, and a fading Jewish heritage. But simply reviewing the decades, even centuries, of ethnic conflict doesn’t offer mush insight into what happens now, today. And in that, I have to plead my own ignorance. I could draw inferences from the news reports I read, or canvass my friends serving in the military to see what they’ve noticed. There are clashes, theft, harassment, rapes, even murders.

None of it, though, captures the real situation on the ground—the real status of Afghanistan’s multitudinous ethnic groups. For that, you must consult one who has actually traveled there, absorbed the sense and feel of the people there. I, sadly, have not.

Editor’s Note: Comments are disabled on this post in order to limit discussion to one venue. Please go to The Registan to post and view comments.

Share and Enjoy:These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • del.icio.us
  • digg
  • YahooMyWeb
  • NewsVine
  • Reddit
  • Furl
  • Ma.gnolia
  • blogmarks
  • Simpy
  • Spurl

Comments are closed.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.

Anonymous Blogging with Wordpress and Tor

ru.neweurasia.net - blogscan

Click on Pic: Kashka-Suu Tourism Complex

May 16th, 2008

Mirsulzhan uploads pictures from the most beautiful place near to Bishkek - Kashka-Suu - after his trip there (KYR).

Beyond Mark Weil

May 16th, 2008

Nick reports about the new BBC documentary dedicated to the murdered director of the Ilkhom theater - Mark Weil (ENG).

Cheap priced democracy

May 16th, 2008

Alisher Taksanov unveils the truth about the unofficial web portal of the Uzbek National Security Service, where a young student wrote about Western democracy (RUS).

Immortal memory of Andijon

May 16th, 2008

Musafirbek writes about the Andijon events saying the memory of this tragedy will forever live in peoples hearts (RUS).

Lame Uzbek tourism

May 16th, 2008

Alisher Taksanov posts an interview with German touristic agency that comments on the Uzbek tourism (RUS).

podCast: If it is so popular to be a Blogger at the moment, so before it was popular to be a Rapper!

May 15th, 2008

Mirsulzhan uploaded another his podcast in russian, where he and his friends talk to Kyrgyz Rappers who wish to win the scene of Europe at least (RUS).

New web resources in Kazakh

May 15th, 2008

Askhat writes that from now it is easier to blog in Kazakh with the new Wordpress platform, tailored for Kazakh-speaking bloggers  (KAZ)

What Rakhat Knows

May 15th, 2008

Adam reviews the Wall Street Journal article, telling that in 2003 Dariga Nazarbayeva, elder daughter of the Kazakhstan president, hired an American consulting firm to collect data on the Kazakhgate trial, a probe into corruption among top Kazakh officials (RUS, ENG). 

Edil Baisalov Appeared

May 15th, 2008

Elena reports about the interview with the young politician Edill Baisalov who left Kyrgyzstan last year (ENG).

Kazakh or ethnic Kazakh?

May 14th, 2008

Özgecan shares her thoughts about Kazakh history from the point of view of a person, who is part of the Kazakh diaspora in the Western Europe (ENG).

Rahmonov and Bakiev Will Discuss the Boundary Problems

May 14th, 2008

Elena tells about a two-day visit of the President of Kyrgyzstan Kurmanbek Bakiev to Tajikistan (ENG).

Cyber-Chaikhana

May 14th, 2008

Elena posted the announcement about the project “Cyber-Chaikhana” (RUS).

Dangerous substances in the Chinese Toys

May 14th, 2008

Elena said that the Kyrgyz experts found the toxic substances in the Chinese toys (RUS).

Cyberchaikhana - Book on Central Asian Blogosphere

May 14th, 2008

Adam posts an announcement with the call for contributions to the neweurasia’s CyberChaikhana book on Central Asian blogosphere (RUS).

Thoughts about Andijon…

May 13th, 2008

Libertad asks readers to share their thoughts about Andijon tragedy, a bloody suppression of a civic demonstration in May 2005 (ENG).

Gas pipeline to China becoming reality

May 13th, 2008

maciula writes about the planned gas pipeline from Turkmenistan to China and notes China’s successful activity in securing its gas interests in Turkmenistan (ENG).

Opposition Offers Controversial Anti-Crisis Measures

May 13th, 2008

Adam reviews the major opposition party’s suggestions on anti-crisis measures (ENG).

Journalists Die Hard in Kazakhstan

May 13th, 2008

Adam says that amidst change of the information ministry in Kazakhstan, the country still ranks very low in the Freddom House Press Freedom Index (RUS).

Discussing New Religion Law

May 12th, 2008

Askhat reviews foreign sites and writes that foreign religious missioners consider that the new Kazakh religion law is very restrictive (KAZ).

Kashagan to Be Two Years Late. Again

May 12th, 2008

Adam reports that the consortium developing the giant Kashagan oil field in the Caspian Sea proposes to postpone the start of production to 2012-2013 from 2011 (ENG).

Veterans are second to show

May 12th, 2008

Publicist tells a sad story of how she attended the May 9th festivities dedicated to the WWII heroes, at which the veterans were treated depreciatingly (RUS).

The secret of suicides in the Kazakh army

May 11th, 2008

Askhat writes that even NGOs that are aimed at monitoring of the Kazakh army issues are unable to disclose any information without the permission of military commissariats (KAZ)

What is going on with the pre-Caspian gas pipeline?

May 11th, 2008

maciula writes about problems with the pre-Caspian gas pipeline project (ENG).

UN adds more Uzbeks to top terrorists list

May 10th, 2008

Libertad writes about new Uzbek people added to the UN consolidated list of suspects affiliated with Al Qaeda and Taliban (ENG).

Victory or Remembrance Day?

May 10th, 2008

Musafirbek congratulates everyone with Victory Remembrance Day (RUS).

Uzbekian nights: president’s hobby

May 10th, 2008

Alisher Taksanov writes a fiction story about a president, whose hobby was to make coffins for opposition members whom he later killed (RUS).

Eastern Promises

May 10th, 2008

Abdulgamid reports on Turkmen government’s promises that denomination of the national currency will be “soft” (RUS).  

AFC Challenge Cup 2008: Kyrgyz win, Afghans qualify

May 9th, 2008

Elena posted some pictures from the last soccer game between Bangladesh and Kyrgyzstan during the AFC Challenge Cup Group C qualifier (ENG)

Cosmic prices for air tickets

May 9th, 2008

Abdulgamid writes about four times rise in prices for air tickets in Turkmenistan (RUS).

Turkmen president removes the statue of his predecessor from the city centre

May 9th, 2008

maciula reports on president Berdymukhammedov’s efforts to undo his predecessor’s personality cult (ENG).