Click for latest discussions
Cyber Chaikhana: Digital Conversations from Central Asia

The Nabucco Project and the West’s Energy Security

Posted by Vasili | in Caucasus, Energy | on April 3rd, 2007
No tag for this post.

The significance of the Caucasus and Central Asia for the Western World is growing as ever. Especially after Putin’s Kremlin has terrified Europe by repeated blackmailing during its quarrel over increased gas prices with the Ukraine in winter of 2005 and with Lukashenka’s authoritarian Belarus in December of 2006.

In 2005, a gas pipeline, running from Russia through Ukraine, supplying 25% of European energy markets, has been shut down. It seems like Europe felt a horrifying chill of the Russian winter coming from the remote prairies of merciless Siberia, flowing through the empty gas pipes.

Apparently the West got finally convinced that an increasingly assertive, anti-western and authoritarian Russia is a dangerously unpredictable energy (and political) partner. After these events, western capitals started to talk even more enthusiastically about diversifying European energy supplies.

Specifically, the West considers transporting abundant Caspian gas and oil resources from Kazakhstan, Turkmenistan and Azerbaijan via the Caucasus and Turkey to Europe, bypassing Russia. This relatively new project is called Nabucco Project. It has been circulating in western political and business circles for quiet sometime already, with more or less intensity.

While the West is still contemplating, the Kremlin has scored a couple more significant victories, thus tightening its grip on European energy markets. On March 15th, President Putin signed a deal in Athens with Bulgaria and Greece to transport Russian oil to the European Union via pipeline bypassing the strait of Bosphorus in Turkey.

The 178 mile long pipeline will go above land from the Black Sea port Burgas (Bulgaria) to Alexandroupolis (Greece) on the Aegean Sea and from there will be shipped to the rest of Europe by oil tankers. The estimated cost of the pipeline will be $1.2 billion. A Russian consortium will hold 51% of the stakes. Bulgaria and Greece will have 24.5% of the stakes each.

Religious and historical factors definitely played their roles in reaching the deal. Despite of their membership in NATO and EU, both Bulgaria and Greece are seen as the most pro-Russian nations in European Union by the Russian political-economic establishment, based on their historical and religious ties with Russia.

First, these countries always allied themselves with Russian Empire in their wars against Turkey in the 18th, 19th and 20th centuries. Second, all of these three countries belong to the same, Eastern Orthodox Christian religious denomination, the fact that ideologically bankrupt Russia wrongfully started to play out in international politics to such an extent that Russian state media even called the new project “Orthodox Christian Pipeline” (“Pravoslavni Trubaprovod”).

This new energy deal resembles an earlier huge gas deal reached between Russia and Germany under Chancellor Gerhard Schroeder in September 2005. Named as The Northern European Gas Pipeline, it entirely bypasses the westward-looking and Russia-wary Poland and Baltic states of Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania.

The 744 mile long pipeline will cost $5 billion and run on the floor of Baltic Sea from the Russian coastal city Wyborg to the north-eastern German city Greisfwald. Russian gas giant Gasprom holds 51% of the shares in the project. German E-ON and BASF taking 24.5% each.

Mr. Schroeder had signed this deal on his way out from the office, just before he was defeated in the German elections in September 2005 by current Chancellor Angela Merkel. Mr. Schroeder now happily works for a Russian Gazprom controlled consortium which appointed him as a Chairman of the Board of The Northern European Gas Pipeline Project. Many in Germany are outraged by former chancellor for leaving Germany and the rest of northern Europe even more dependent on Russian gas.

On March 15th, President Putin and Italian Prime Minister Prodi signed a deal in Italian city of Bari allowing Russian gas giant Gazprom to sell 3 billion cubic meters of gas to main Italian gas company ENI, thus immensely increasing Italian dependence on Russian gas in the future.

However, contrary to expectations, this deal doesn’t give ENI access to Russian energy reserves, the fact that prompted further criticism and reservations in Italian business and political circles. Besides, Russia still refuses to sign the European Energy Charter, denying European energy companies fair competition and access to Russia’s energy sources.

The sudden death of Turkmenistan’s authoritarian ruler Safarmurat Niazov (or as he was known at home and abroad “Turkmenbashi” - “Father of the Turkmens”) brings with it a possibility to alter the overall picture of European energy policy. Under Niazov’s rule Russia remained Turkmenistan’s main energy customer, buying cheap Turkmen gas ($66 per thousand cubic meter) and selling it in Europe for a four times higher price.

As of 2006, the price for Turkmen gas rose, reaching $100 per thousand cubic meter. However, the Kremlin still almost makes a threefold profit on cheap Turkmen gas, while at the same time having an easy access to the country’s abundant gas recourses.

The coming to power of a new Turkmen administration under the leadership of President Gurbanguly Berdymukhammedov creates a momentum for change on Central Asian and European energy markets. The new government is giving hopeful signs that the country, so long isolated from the world, might be opening up, willing to attract western investments for its sluggish economy.

The Western interest for Turkmen gas is ever increasing, promising the country that it can export its gas to western markets at fair, world market prices, benefiting Turkmenistan’s inefficient and struggling economy. EU, American, Georgian, Turkish and Azerbaijani officials and diplomats are intensifying their work with new Turkmen government in Ashgabat over the possibility of the new project for the transportation of Turkmen gas to Europe through the Caspian Sea and the Caucasus.

The prospects of directing Central Asian energy resources to Europe opens a new chapter for the Caucasian states of Georgia and Azerbaijan, promising them with increased status and security on the international stage.

The International Oil, Gas, Infrastructures and Energy conference (GIOGIE) that opened in the Georgian capital Tbilisi on March 22 focused exactly on this issue. US Ambassador to Georgia John Tefft underlined the US government’s desire to diversify western energy supplies and suppliers and to promote the project of building new pipelines to transport Turkmen gas and Kazakh oil from the Caspian Sea, via Azerbaijan, Georgia and Turkey towards western energy markets.

The Caucasus, specifically Georgia and Azerbaijan, already host three western supported, sponsored and built pipelines of regional importance.

The first one, called Baku-Supsa pipeline, is of lesser scale. Its length is 550 miles, transporting about 125,000 barrels of crude oil a day from the Azerbaijani capital Baku to the Georgian oil terminal Supsa on the Black Sea coast before being shipped to western Europe.

The second one is of much larger scale, known as Baku-Batumi-Ceyhan pipeline. This 1,100 mile long pipeline transports 800, 000 barrels a day of Azerbaijani oil from the Caspian Sea to the Turkish port Ceyhan via the Georgian port Batumi.

The third one is a gas pipeline, named Baku-Tbilisi-Erzurum pipeline (also known as Shah-Deniz pipeline). It pumps gas from Azerbaijan’s giant offshore gas fields, crossing Azerbaijan and Georgia before reaching the Turkish city Erzurum. The pipeline’s output reaches 19 million cubic meters of gas per day.

The abovementioned Nabucco Project, along with already existing projects, is of great significance in several ways. It further increases the role of the Caucasus, particularly of Georgia and Azerbaijan, as an energy corridor for western energy supplies flowing from Central Asia and eastern Azerbaijan.

It strengthens national independence of both Georgia and Azerbaijan and counterbalances the overwhelming political and economic influence of Russia in the south Caucasus. It creates one long, solid axis of economic, political and security cooperation stretching from Kazakhstan to the Mediterranean Sea (including Turkey) and brings this whole region even closer to western political-economic sphere.

If the Nabucco Project is fully realized, it will be even more difficult for an increasingly aggressive Russia to try to regain its influence over any of the countries involved in the project, since it would break the chain of energy supply, jeopardize western energy security and provoke a swift reaction from the western world in defense of a victim country.

The Nabucco Project can break the Russian monopoly over the transportation of Central Asian energy resources to the West and thus weaken Russia’s political and economic clout as a main energy supplier in its dealings with Europe and ex-Soviet republics.

At the same time, the Nabucco Project enables Kazakhstan and Turkmenistan to divert their energy routes from Russia, strengthening their independence and benefitting their economies and populations from fair international prices for their energy commodities.

Western governments must fully understand the future potential of the Nabucco Project and more actively engage the Central Asian governments of Kazakhstan and especially of Turkmenistan to make this project come true. This is a project that creates an unique chance for peace, security, prosperity and further democratization of the Caucasus and Central Asia.

For Europe it is a unique possibility to establish alternative energy supplies. Needless to say, the project is equally significant for those that will receive supplies (Europe) and those who will supply and transport (Central Asia and Caucasus). It creates a fertile ground for short and long-term cooperation and partnership among the regions and this chance simply can not be missed.

Vasili Rukhadze holds M.A. degree in Political Science from the City University of New York.

Share and Enjoy:These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • del.icio.us
  • digg
  • YahooMyWeb
  • NewsVine
  • Reddit
  • Furl
  • Ma.gnolia
  • blogmarks
  • Simpy
  • Spurl

One Response to this post.

Subscribe to comments with RSS or TrackBack .

Comments

Trackbacks/Pings


Leave a reply

  • Please treat others with respect.
  • Comments containing hate speech, obscenity, and personal attacks will not be approved.

Anonymous Blogging with Wordpress and Tor

ru.neweurasia.net - blogscan

Re housing construction under Soviet Union

August 20th, 2008

Marat posts some statistical figures about housing construction and affordability of housing in Kazakhstan in the Soviet times (ENG, RUS).

Food crisis

August 20th, 2008

Shannon reports about the sriking numbers of food crisis in Tajikistan (ENG).

Restriction Of Use of Electric Power Will Start Soon

August 19th, 2008

Elena announces that the limitation of the usage of the electric power will start on 21th August (RUS).

Kazakh business abroad

August 19th, 2008

Adam reports that the Russia-based business structures controlled by Kazakhstani banker Mukhtar Ablyazov are consolidated in the largest Russian developing company (RUS).

Astana Impressions

August 19th, 2008

Ben shares his impressions from Astana, the growing new capital city of Kazakhstan (ENG).

Kazakh perspectives on the Russian-Georgian War

August 19th, 2008

Ben opines on the implications of the new Caucasus conflict for Kazakhstan and says that Kazakhstan’s president Nazarbayev has been the first CIS leader to make a statement on the conflict during a meeting with Putin in Beijing (ENG).

American Basketball Players to Visit Kyrgyzstan

August 19th, 2008

Elena reports that American basketball players will visit Kyrgyzstan to participate in a series of sporting events (ENG).

Friday Photo: Kustanai

August 17th, 2008

Nurgeldy posts a picture of a new small sculpture erected in Kustanai (RUS, ENG).

Hadj-2008 Will Cost 2400 USD

August 17th, 2008

Elena reports that the cost of Hadj-2008 for Kyrgyz citizens is 2400 USD (RUS).

Official Information About Prison Incident

August 17th, 2008

Elena publishes official information about the incident in a prison where 2 prison officials were killed by convicts (ENG).

Inmates Killed Two Prison Officials

August 15th, 2008

Elena reports that inmates at a prison have staged a riot and killed two prison officials (RUS).

iPod in Jailoo

August 14th, 2008

Ben presents an interesting photo of a Kyrgyz woman with an iPod in jailoo (ENG).

Kyrgyz Deputies Leave for Tskhinvali

August 14th, 2008

Elena writes about the Kyrgyz deputies who have left for Tshinvali to offer peacekeeping negotiation services in the ongoing Georgia conflict (ENG).

Fund in the name of Olympic medalist

August 14th, 2008

Vadim reports that a Tajik businessman decided to establish a fund in the name of first Tajik Olympic medalist (ENG).

First Olympic Medal Ever

August 14th, 2008

Vadim and Ravshan report that a Tajik judoka secured for Tajikistan its first Olympic medal (ENG) and (RUS).

Uzbek government silent on conflict in South Ossetia

August 14th, 2008

Libertad translates a post about the Uzbek government’s silence on the developments in South Ossetia (ENG).

Uzbek language TV channels are at a risk of closure in Kyrgyzstan

August 13th, 2008

Tolkun writes about the new language regulations for broadcast mass media in Kyrgyzstan and its possible effects on Uzbek language media of the country (ENG).

Uzbek government still keeps low profile on South Ossetia

August 13th, 2008

Musafirbek writes that the Uzbek government prefers not comment on conflicts of international importance, and gives cases of South Ossetia and Kosovo (RUS).

Kyrgyzstan Received Military Technical Aid from China

August 13th, 2008

Elena tells that China provided the military technical aid 4 million yuan to Kyrgyzstan (ENG).

Kyrgyzstan Got Olympic Silver

August 13th, 2008

Elena reports about the second medal for the wrestling in Kyrgyzstan team (ENG).

Kazakh Olympic sportsmen’s style

August 13th, 2008

The Kazakh Olympic sportsmen’s style is a hot topic among American bloggers, and Askhat has noticed that Americans often mention Borat when Kazakh sportsmen win a prize (KAZ)

Memoral Evening in Honour of Chingiz Aitmatov to be Held in Astana

August 13th, 2008

Elena reports that there will be a memorial event in the honour of Chingiz Aitmatov during the V International Film Festival “Eurasia” in Astana (RUS).

British ex-premier’s son served Kazakh oilmen

August 13th, 2008

Zhanna Zhukova reviews allegations that Sir Mark Thatcher, son of the British ex-prime-minister Margaret Thatcher, was hired by a private Kazakh oil company to lobby for its interests and to enhance Kazakhstan’s image abroad (ENG).

Mark Thatcher loves Kazakhs, too

August 13th, 2008

Adam translates the article in the British Times, which reports that Margareth Thatcher’s son allegedly was hired by Kazakh oilmen to promote Kazakhstan’s image abroad (RUS).

New Fines for the Traffic Violation

August 12th, 2008

Elena writes about the new fines for the traffic violation (RUS).

South Ossetia: Russian Commentators Attacked Kyrgyz Blogs

August 12th, 2008

Mirsulzhan writes about his experience discussing the events in South Ossetia on his personal blog and describes the rapid appearance of more than 100 comments to the post, most of whcih were against his position (KYR).

Uzbek government silent on Georgia

August 12th, 2008

Alisher Taksanov writes about the Uzbek government’s silence on the developments between Russia and Georgia — long tongue lives short? (RUS)

Tashkent 2200 - #1

August 12th, 2008

Libertad and Musafirbek upload the first pictures of Tashkent from the call for pictures to celebrate the 2200th anniversary of the capital (ENG, RUS).

No more Kyrgyz electricity to Ferghana valley

August 12th, 2008

Libertad writes about a new high-voltage electricity line from Angren to the Ferghana Valley that will enable the Uzbek government to secure its energy independence (ENG).

First Totals of the Kyrgyz Team at the Olympic Games in Beijing

August 11th, 2008

Elena reports on the first totals for the Kyrgyz team at the Olympic Games in Beijing (ENG).