Click for latest discussions

Uzbekistan: Unwanted Changes

Posted by Tolkun | in Blogosphere | on May 12th, 2008

After the disintegration of the USSR, the Soviet communist identity and ideology ceased to exist and the new countries confronted the vital problems of defining new identities and ideologies. Most of the ex-Soviet countries were quick to give up the past and embrace the new life with new national values and ideas. Uzbekistan was one of the few countries where a process of defining a new identity and setting up new national values went in a very rapid manner.

The changing cultural and political atmosphere was first reflected throughout Uzbekistan through renaming of squares, streets and parks from Soviet-type names into symbols of  either independence or national identity. All Soviet monuments were dismantled, being replaced with the heroes of Uzbek history. For the last two weeks, the Uzbek blogosphere discussed changes that were happenning in the post-Soviet period in Uzbekistan.

Provincialka at neweurasia says that Uzbekistan underwent serious changes that after the collapse of the Soviet Union, and writes that the new Uzbek government headed by Islam Karimov included new holidays to country’s calendar and entirely changed the ones that used to be celebrated in Soviet times.

I look at the calendar and I’m really surprised to see the governments trying to change the history and eradicate the memory of the past… The Labor Day, May 1, that used to be widely celebrated [in Soviet times], is totally forgotten in the country. However, those citizens, who lived during the Soviet time, still remember this day…

The Victory Day, May 9, would not be celebrated if not those WWII veterans, who are still alive today. However, it is not celebrated as a Victory Day. A long time has passed since it was renamed to the Remembrance Day, a day to remember those fellow countrymen, who died due to the war and J.Stalin’s repressions. Respecting the memory of those repressed and those who died on the battlefield, I would suggest to have two different days for remembering their souls [ru].

Musafirbek at neweurasia congratulates everyone with the Victory Day and says that “it does not matter how this day is called i different countries, what matters is that this victory is a result of a unity, friendship and heroism of different nations” [ru].

The new government is not only changing the holidays and streets names, but also removing old monuments. Dismantling of one of the most respected memories in Tashkent - the International Friendship monument - is one of such cases. It had been erected in memory of the Shamakhmudovs, who adopted 15 orphans in the WWII and became a symbol of generosity and humanism of the Uzbek people.

The article by Fergana.ru generated a lot of comments, where readers shared with each other their thoughts concerning the dismantling of the monument. Emigrant says:

Tell me, who needs such independence? Infrastructure of Tashkent is worsening from year to year… The Uzbek government seems to be gone mad, as it is destroying the memory and history of Uzbek nation. Politicians come and go, but memory lives forever [ru].

Another change that came to the country after the collapse of the Soviet Union is the change of the Uzbek alphabet from Cyrillic to Latin. The change brought a lot of inconveniences for Uzbek nation, as the old generation has difficulties in reading the Latin alphabet. While print media is remaining in Cyrillic, the sings, boards and ads in the streets are in Latin. The recent developments in the country show that now people are converting Russian into Latin alphabet! A blog RealUzbekistan is so far the first to raise this problem in media.

Also posted on Global Voices Online.

Share and Enjoy:These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • del.icio.us
  • digg
  • YahooMyWeb
  • NewsVine
  • Reddit
  • Furl
  • Ma.gnolia
  • blogmarks
  • Simpy
  • Spurl

2 Responses to this post.

Subscribe to comments with RSS or TrackBack .

Comments

  1. Ataman Rakin said,

    on May 14th, 2008 at 4:17 pm

    I am rather in favor of Latinisation. Why? If the Uzbek and other Turkic languages in the region are to keep some sort of position in today’s world or even in Eurasia, it will have to join up in a wider language sphere with a leading language and that is obviously Turkish.

    Besides ca. 70 million speakers, Turkish already has a Latin alphabet adapted to Turkic sounds (ç, ş, ı, ğ, c, … ), and adapted IT and printing technology.

    The Latinisation process has taken quite well in Azerbaijan and (seems so) Turkmenistan. But the way it was done in Uzbekistan (with sound letters or letter combinations copied straight from English) is clumsy and neither fish nor fowl.

    The same reasoning applies, IMO, for Tajik which is not really a language but sovietised, castrated Farsi. If it is to keep some position it will have to join up in a wider Farsi sphere and that means re-adopting the Farsi-Arabic alphabet.

    BTW, the whole Uzbek national identity that the regime constructed after the USSR (Özbekçilik, the Timur cult, … ) is a completely artificial, neo-Soviet (in fact Lenin is merely remplaced by Timur) concept that holds little ground among the people.

    Indeed if you go deeper into Uzbek or ohter Central Asian identities then you see basically two elements that come up: the Soviet-colonial experience, and Islam.

Trackbacks/Pings


Leave a reply

  • Please treat others with respect.
  • Comments containing hate speech, obscenity, and personal attacks will not be approved.

Anonymous Blogging with Wordpress and Tor

ru.neweurasia.net - blogscan

Friday Photo: The Panfilovs Park

May 16th, 2008

Herico posts a rendered picture of the picturesque park in the downtown of Almaty (ENG, RUS).

Click on Pic: Kashka-Suu Tourism Complex

May 16th, 2008

Mirsulzhan uploads pictures from the most beautiful place near to Bishkek - Kashka-Suu - after his trip there (KYR).

Beyond Mark Weil

May 16th, 2008

Nick reports about the new BBC documentary dedicated to the murdered director of the Ilkhom theater - Mark Weil (ENG).

Cheap priced democracy

May 16th, 2008

Alisher Taksanov unveils the truth about the unofficial web portal of the Uzbek National Security Service, where a young student wrote about Western democracy (RUS).

Immortal memory of Andijon

May 16th, 2008

Musafirbek writes about the Andijon events saying the memory of this tragedy will forever live in peoples hearts (RUS).

Lame Uzbek tourism

May 16th, 2008

Alisher Taksanov posts an interview with German touristic agency that comments on the Uzbek tourism (RUS).

podCast: If it is so popular to be a Blogger at the moment, so before it was popular to be a Rapper!

May 15th, 2008

Mirsulzhan uploaded another his podcast in russian, where he and his friends talk to Kyrgyz Rappers who wish to win the scene of Europe at least (RUS).

New web resources in Kazakh

May 15th, 2008

Askhat writes that from now it is easier to blog in Kazakh with the new Wordpress platform, tailored for Kazakh-speaking bloggers  (KAZ)

What Rakhat Knows

May 15th, 2008

Adam reviews the Wall Street Journal article, telling that in 2003 Dariga Nazarbayeva, elder daughter of the Kazakhstan president, hired an American consulting firm to collect data on the Kazakhgate trial, a probe into corruption among top Kazakh officials (RUS, ENG). 

Edil Baisalov Appeared

May 15th, 2008

Elena reports about the interview with the young politician Edill Baisalov who left Kyrgyzstan last year (ENG).

Kazakh or ethnic Kazakh?

May 14th, 2008

Özgecan shares her thoughts about Kazakh history from the point of view of a person, who is part of the Kazakh diaspora in the Western Europe (ENG).

Rahmonov and Bakiev Will Discuss the Boundary Problems

May 14th, 2008

Elena tells about a two-day visit of the President of Kyrgyzstan Kurmanbek Bakiev to Tajikistan (ENG).

Cyber-Chaikhana

May 14th, 2008

Elena posted the announcement about the project “Cyber-Chaikhana” (RUS).

Dangerous substances in the Chinese Toys

May 14th, 2008

Elena said that the Kyrgyz experts found the toxic substances in the Chinese toys (RUS).

Cyberchaikhana - Book on Central Asian Blogosphere

May 14th, 2008

Adam posts an announcement with the call for contributions to the neweurasia’s CyberChaikhana book on Central Asian blogosphere (RUS).

Thoughts about Andijon…

May 13th, 2008

Libertad asks readers to share their thoughts about Andijon tragedy, a bloody suppression of a civic demonstration in May 2005 (ENG).

Gas pipeline to China becoming reality

May 13th, 2008

maciula writes about the planned gas pipeline from Turkmenistan to China and notes China’s successful activity in securing its gas interests in Turkmenistan (ENG).

Opposition Offers Controversial Anti-Crisis Measures

May 13th, 2008

Adam reviews the major opposition party’s suggestions on anti-crisis measures (ENG).

Journalists Die Hard in Kazakhstan

May 13th, 2008

Adam says that amidst change of the information ministry in Kazakhstan, the country still ranks very low in the Freddom House Press Freedom Index (RUS).

Discussing New Religion Law

May 12th, 2008

Askhat reviews foreign sites and writes that foreign religious missioners consider that the new Kazakh religion law is very restrictive (KAZ).

Kashagan to Be Two Years Late. Again

May 12th, 2008

Adam reports that the consortium developing the giant Kashagan oil field in the Caspian Sea proposes to postpone the start of production to 2012-2013 from 2011 (ENG).

Veterans are second to show

May 12th, 2008

Publicist tells a sad story of how she attended the May 9th festivities dedicated to the WWII heroes, at which the veterans were treated depreciatingly (RUS).

The secret of suicides in the Kazakh army

May 11th, 2008

Askhat writes that even NGOs that are aimed at monitoring of the Kazakh army issues are unable to disclose any information without the permission of military commissariats (KAZ)

What is going on with the pre-Caspian gas pipeline?

May 11th, 2008

maciula writes about problems with the pre-Caspian gas pipeline project (ENG).

UN adds more Uzbeks to top terrorists list

May 10th, 2008

Libertad writes about new Uzbek people added to the UN consolidated list of suspects affiliated with Al Qaeda and Taliban (ENG).

Victory or Remembrance Day?

May 10th, 2008

Musafirbek congratulates everyone with Victory Remembrance Day (RUS).

Uzbekian nights: president’s hobby

May 10th, 2008

Alisher Taksanov writes a fiction story about a president, whose hobby was to make coffins for opposition members whom he later killed (RUS).

Eastern Promises

May 10th, 2008

Abdulgamid reports on Turkmen government’s promises that denomination of the national currency will be “soft” (RUS).  

AFC Challenge Cup 2008: Kyrgyz win, Afghans qualify

May 9th, 2008

Elena posted some pictures from the last soccer game between Bangladesh and Kyrgyzstan during the AFC Challenge Cup Group C qualifier (ENG)

Cosmic prices for air tickets

May 9th, 2008

Abdulgamid writes about four times rise in prices for air tickets in Turkmenistan (RUS).