Click for latest discussions

Press Freedom in Central Asia and the Caucasus

Posted by Neil | in Current Events, Internet | on October 5th, 2006
No tag for this post.

Welcome to another roundup on regional freedom of the press.

The major news on media freedom from the Central Asian region in the past month is the death in Turkmen custody of the RFE correspondent Ogulsapar Muradova, who was sentenced to six years in prison in August. Although Turkmen authorities claimed the reporter died of natural causes, it seems more likely that she died under torture.

Her death has been condemned by the UN, the UNHCR, and Human Rights Watch, as well as many other international organisations. There are now fears for her family, who are now being held inncomunicado. Reportwers without Borders is gathering signatures for a petition calling for an investigation, as well as the release of the two other activists jailed at the same trial.

In Kazakhstan, two suspects have been arrested over the recent murder of a French journalist in Alamty. The Kazakh authorities maintain his death was unrelated to his work.

On the Kazakhstan country weblog, Leila looks how blogging is taking off there, and how it could be affected by media laws.

Across the border in Kyrgyzstan, the opposition have charged that state television has presented a biased view of the recent drug planting scandal in which President Bakiev’s brother allegedly attempted to frame oppostiion leader Omurbek Tekebaev.

Also in Bishkek, Pyramid TV, Kyrgyzstan’s oldest independent station, was temporarily put off air by an arson attack in which two technicians were also beaten up. The station is reguarly critical of Bakiev’s administration and this is not the first time it has been attacked.

RFE has a useful primer on Uzbek pro- and anti-government websites, and reports that “Uzbekistan’s security services are actively blocking websites they dislike, a category that includes virtually all of the above-listed sites that publish anything critical of the government.”

However, the Uzbek authorities are also capable of more traditional methods of censorship. One of the few remaining independent journalists in Uzbekistan, Jamshid Karimov, who also happens to be President Karimov’s nephew, was apparently framed on bribery charges and has since been committed to a Samarkand psychiatric hospital. The Uzbek authorities have used the same technique to deal with human rights activists, and the sending of dissidents to psychiatric hospitals was pioneered during Soviet times.

Our final piece of news from Uzbekistan is that the newspaper ‘Tasvir+TV’ is being investigated for publishing articles which offend ‘the Uzbek people’s mentality’. The articles in question look at the sexuality of Tchaikovsky and sexual relations through history. There’s also a great piece of doublethink in the article from an Uzbek official - any sanctions taken against the paper ’should not be regarded as restrictions on media freedom’.

EurasiaNet reports that the Tajik authorities are clamping down on independent media in the run-up to the Presidential election - even as President Rahmonov’s speeches get star billing. The OSCE has launched a web portal on the Asia Plus site in order to give all candidates balanced coverage.

The OSCE has also been busy in the Caucasus. Both the Yerevan and Baku offices of the organisation have issued press releases expressing concern following recent attacks and lawsuits against journalists.

One of the lawsuits in question is that against Azeri newspaper editor Eynulla Fatullayev, who was sued for libel by former interior minister Ramil Usubov. Another Azeri journalist, Sakid Zahidov, has just been sentenced to three years in jail on dubious drug charges.

Finally, here’s a look at the role of television in Georgia’s municipal elections, being held tomorrow. The recent Russian spy scandal has been heavily covered in Georgian media, and some believe the coverage will work in the Government’s favour.

New TOL/neweurasia publications

Posted by Ben | in Blogosphere, Internet | on September 29th, 2006
No tag for this post.


An Easy Guide to Blogging by Nathan Hamm

This introductory guide acts as a very good starter for newcomers to the world of blogging. Sections include: ‘What is a Blog?’, ‘The Blogosphere’, ‘Why Blog?’, ‘Building a Successful Blog’, ‘Writing a Successful Post’ and ‘Ethics’.

Available in English | Russian | Uzbek




Safe Blogging & Online Privacy Made Easy

There are already a few freely available guides to online privacy and safe blogging, but we at neweurasia and Transitions Online seek to provide a succinct, easy-to-understand summary for those who wish to blog anonymously.

Available in: English | Russian | Uzbek

Our new resource section is here, and it also features a growing list of external documents.

Remittances: the New Foreign Aid?

Posted by James | in Blogosphere, Events, Internet | on May 17th, 2006
No tag for this post.

Open Source will be hosting a podcast discussion on remittances this Thursday, and they are interested in the Central Asian perspective on this issue. So if you are intrigued by the subject of remittances (“the new foreign aid?� they ask) and know something about the situation in Eurasia, head on over. They are looking for testimonies and first-person accounts.

Are remittances better suited to help small communities than aid, or are they just signs that aid is failing? What does it mean that workers are making these kinds of sacrifices, and what will it mean when governments learn to depend on those sacrifices? Are remittances a viable development strategy?

Press Freedom in Central Asia

Posted by Neil | in Internet, Politics, The wider region | on March 11th, 2006
No tag for this post.

Welcome to the second roundup of news on press freedom in Central Asia and the Caucasus.

We’ll start in Kazakhstan, where the radical opposition newspaper ‘Juma Times’ has been ordered to close. The paper was charged with insulting the ‘honour and dignity’ of President Nazarbayev in the run-up to last year’s elections.

Gulzhan Yergaliyeva, the editor of another opposition newspaper, Svoboda Slovo, has been jailed for holding an ‘unsanctioned demonstration’ on the death of Altynbek Sarsenbayev. Yergaliyeva has gone on hunger strike to protest against her imprisonment.

On the Turkmenistan blog, Peter reports on the March 7 arrest of two RFE/RL Journalists. As of March 10, their whereabouts are still unknown, and the telephone lines to all other RFE/RL correspondents in the country have been blocked.

The Tajik Ministry of Communications is aiming to tighten control over internet service providers and international telecoms, through a plan to route all telephone and intenet traffic ‘Unified Communications Center and Information Resource Unit’. However, there are doubts as to whether the Government’s plan is feasible.

Nick discusses a new resolution from the Uzbek Government which strenghtens the regulations on foreign journalists on the Uzbekistan blog.

Meanwhile, in further bad news for RFE/RL, two former Uzbek employees have attacked the service. Rakhmatzhan Kuldashev, the ex-head of the Tashkent bureau, is demanding $20,000 compensation from his former employer, claiming that ‘Humiliation and poverty are all I got for my faithful service’. Another ex-correspondent, Khusniddin Kutbiddinov, has written an open letter in which he states that the Uzbek Government is ‘much more humane’ than RFE/RL.

In Azerbaijan, an opposition journalist was brutally attacked. Fikret Huseynli, who has been threatened in the past for his work on exposing corruption in the Azeri Governemnt, was left in a critical condition. The attack came almost a year after the still unsolved murder of journalist Elmar Husneyov.

Journalists in Georgia suffer from a different type of threat to their work. The media owners who control many major outlets appear uninterested in encouraging investigative journalism, fearing that it may damage their market position and relations with the Government.

Finally, here’s an interesting report on RFE/RL on increasing coverage of previously-taboo religious issues by non-traditional media sources, including the internet, in Central Asian countries.

Press Freedom in Central Asia

Posted by Neil | in Internet, neweurasia blogs | on February 8th, 2006
No tag for this post.

Welcome to the first of what will be a semi-regular roundup of news on press freedom and freedom of expression in Central Asia. We’ll start with the recently-published Reporters Without Borders Press Freedom Index for 2005, which provides some useful background on the subject. Out of 167 countries surveyed, none of the ‘Stans manage into the top 100 - Kyrgyzstan leads in 111th place, followed by Tajikistan at 113, Kazakhstan at 119 and at Uzbekistan at 155, with the ‘black hole’ of Turkmenistan scraping in at 165. Only Eritrea and North Korea fare worse.

As if to prove the point, the Turkmenbashi has just personally sentenced a journalist to eight years in prison - apparently for ‘treason’. In brighter news, the OSCE has recently been making efforts to encourage journalism in Turkmenistan, but so far only in the environmental field.

In Kyrgyzstan, the independent media have been suffering from a “wave of threats and intimidation”. There’s evidence for this from IWPR’s report that the Bishkek prosecutor’s office has warned newspapers which criticise President Bakiev may face legal action. In addition, journalists have rallied to support the editor of the newspaper ‘Kyrgyzstan Flag’, who was sacked for being too independent. His replacement? The head of the Government’s PR department.

Kazakhstan’s main printing company, which happens to be owned by President Nazarbayev’s sister-in-law, Svetlana Nazarbayeva, has refused to publish seven opposition newspapers. Kazakh television viewers will also soon have a new channel to watch. However, don’t expect huge ratings - it will be run by Otan, the main pro-government party.

In Tajikstan, James recently discussed how the Communications Ministry has been cracking down on local independent broadcasters. That has now been followed up by the suspension of BBC FM broadcasts, supposedly for ‘administrative reasons’. More on this from James and Tajik Boy here and here.

The IREX Media sustainability report on Uzbekistan has already been covered by Nick in detail. In a further blow to what remains of the free Uzbek press, journalists have not permitted at trial of the opposition leader Sandzhar Umarov.

Finally, RFE/RL recently carried an interview with the head of Reporters Without Borders’ post-Soviet section, regarding the rather dim prospects for press freedom in Turkmenistan and Uzbekistan in 2006.

New data on internet usage

Posted by Ben | in Internet | on January 15th, 2006
No tag for this post.

Two stories have caught my attention lately, one of them thanks to Nathan’s superb collection of daily links. Uzbekistan released new numbers regarding internet penetration and mobile phone usage that are interesting to read. RIA Novosti has the article, according to which in 2005, 855,000 people were online (a 32.9% increase from 2004), and 1.15 million people used mobile phones (a 100% increase from 2004).

Uzbekistan, with a PPP GDP per capita of $1,800, does not compare badly to countries with similar economic raw data, at least from what I can briefly skim over at the CIA.

In terms of a Central Asian perspective, this PDF from a presentation given during an OSCE conference on the Internet in Central Asia and the Caucasus, can give provide some comparative data:

Percentage of Population Using Internet at Least Once a Week in Central Asia, 2005 Figures:
• Kazakhstan: 9% (2002: 3%)
• Kyrgyzstan: 3% (2003: 2%)
• Tajikistan: 4% (2003: 1-3%)
• Turkmenistan: 1% (2001: .1%)
• Uzbekistan: 3% (2003: 2%)

One hindrance to regular internet usage is the financial aspect: Internet is still prohibitively expensive in many countries of the former Soviet Union. According to BakuToday, internet is cheapest in Azerbaijan. You’ll surf for $0.15-0.40 per hour in any of the internet cafés, and the speed of the connection is relatively fast.

The OSCE conference paper again has some more comparative data:

Kazakhstan: dial-up is as low as $ .40/hour and at Internet café is $.50 – 1.92/hour. Average monthly salary $220/month.
Kyrgyzstan: dial-up is as low as $ .20/hour and at Internet café is $.50 – 1.00/hour. Average monthly salary $40/month.
Tajikistan: dial-up is as low as $ .50/hour and at Internet café is $.50 – 1.50/hour. Average monthly salary $30/month.
Turkmenistan: dial-up accounts still almost impossible to obtain. Internet at some hotels is about $2/hour. Average monthly salary $75/month.
Uzbekistan: dial-up is as low as $ .50/hour and at Internet café is $.50 – 1.00/hour. Average monthly salary $35/month.

I remember walking through Ashgabat, looking for a hotel with internet access. The Sheraton (if I remember correctly) had two computers in a closet, and a technician had to come first to get us connected. Had you exchanged your dollars into manat using the official exchange rate, one hour of slow internet would have set you back about $20. Luckily, as we exchanged our money on the black market, it meant we had to pay only about a quarter of that.

Anonymous Blogging with Wordpress and Tor

ru.neweurasia.net - blogscan

Beyond Mark Weil

May 16th, 2008

Nick reports about the new BBC documentary dedicated to the murdered director of the Ilkhom theater - Mark Weil (ENG).

Cheap priced democracy

May 16th, 2008

Alisher Taksanov unveils the truth about the unofficial web portal of the Uzbek National Security Service, where a young student wrote about Western democracy (RUS).

Immortal memory of Andijon

May 16th, 2008

Musafirbek writes about the Andijon events saying the memory of this tragedy will forever live in peoples hearts (RUS).

Lame Uzbek tourism

May 16th, 2008

Alisher Taksanov posts an interview with German touristic agency that comments on the Uzbek tourism (RUS).

podCast: If it is so popular to be a Blogger at the moment, so before it was popular to be a Rapper!

May 15th, 2008

Mirsulzhan uploaded another his podcast in russian, where he and his friends talk to Kyrgyz Rappers who wish to win the scene of Europe at least (RUS).

New web resources in Kazakh

May 15th, 2008

Askhat writes that from now it is easier to blog in Kazakh with the new Wordpress platform, tailored for Kazakh-speaking bloggers  (KAZ)

What Rakhat Knows

May 15th, 2008

Adam reviews the Wall Street Journal article, telling that in 2003 Dariga Nazarbayeva, elder daughter of the Kazakhstan president, hired an American consulting firm to collect data on the Kazakhgate trial, a probe into corruption among top Kazakh officials (RUS, ENG). 

Edil Baisalov Appeared

May 15th, 2008

Elena reports about the interview with the young politician Edill Baisalov who left Kyrgyzstan last year (ENG).

Kazakh or ethnic Kazakh?

May 14th, 2008

Özgecan shares her thoughts about Kazakh history from the point of view of a person, who is part of the Kazakh diaspora in the Western Europe (ENG).

Rahmonov and Bakiev Will Discuss the Boundary Problems

May 14th, 2008

Elena tells about a two-day visit of the President of Kyrgyzstan Kurmanbek Bakiev to Tajikistan (ENG).

Cyber-Chaikhana

May 14th, 2008

Elena posted the announcement about the project “Cyber-Chaikhana” (RUS).

Dangerous substances in the Chinese Toys

May 14th, 2008

Elena said that the Kyrgyz experts found the toxic substances in the Chinese toys (RUS).

Cyberchaikhana - Book on Central Asian Blogosphere

May 14th, 2008

Adam posts an announcement with the call for contributions to the neweurasia’s CyberChaikhana book on Central Asian blogosphere (RUS).

Thoughts about Andijon…

May 13th, 2008

Libertad asks readers to share their thoughts about Andijon tragedy, a bloody suppression of a civic demonstration in May 2005 (ENG).

Gas pipeline to China becoming reality

May 13th, 2008

maciula writes about the planned gas pipeline from Turkmenistan to China and notes China’s successful activity in securing its gas interests in Turkmenistan (ENG).

Opposition Offers Controversial Anti-Crisis Measures

May 13th, 2008

Adam reviews the major opposition party’s suggestions on anti-crisis measures (ENG).

Journalists Die Hard in Kazakhstan

May 13th, 2008

Adam says that amidst change of the information ministry in Kazakhstan, the country still ranks very low in the Freddom House Press Freedom Index (RUS).

Discussing New Religion Law

May 12th, 2008

Askhat reviews foreign sites and writes that foreign religious missioners consider that the new Kazakh religion law is very restrictive (KAZ).

Kashagan to Be Two Years Late. Again

May 12th, 2008

Adam reports that the consortium developing the giant Kashagan oil field in the Caspian Sea proposes to postpone the start of production to 2012-2013 from 2011 (ENG).

Veterans are second to show

May 12th, 2008

Publicist tells a sad story of how she attended the May 9th festivities dedicated to the WWII heroes, at which the veterans were treated depreciatingly (RUS).

The secret of suicides in the Kazakh army

May 11th, 2008

Askhat writes that even NGOs that are aimed at monitoring of the Kazakh army issues are unable to disclose any information without the permission of military commissariats (KAZ)

What is going on with the pre-Caspian gas pipeline?

May 11th, 2008

maciula writes about problems with the pre-Caspian gas pipeline project (ENG).

UN adds more Uzbeks to top terrorists list

May 10th, 2008

Libertad writes about new Uzbek people added to the UN consolidated list of suspects affiliated with Al Qaeda and Taliban (ENG).

Victory or Remembrance Day?

May 10th, 2008

Musafirbek congratulates everyone with Victory Remembrance Day (RUS).

Uzbekian nights: president’s hobby

May 10th, 2008

Alisher Taksanov writes a fiction story about a president, whose hobby was to make coffins for opposition members whom he later killed (RUS).

Eastern Promises

May 10th, 2008

Abdulgamid reports on Turkmen government’s promises that denomination of the national currency will be “soft” (RUS).  

AFC Challenge Cup 2008: Kyrgyz win, Afghans qualify

May 9th, 2008

Elena posted some pictures from the last soccer game between Bangladesh and Kyrgyzstan during the AFC Challenge Cup Group C qualifier (ENG)

Cosmic prices for air tickets

May 9th, 2008

Abdulgamid writes about four times rise in prices for air tickets in Turkmenistan (RUS).

Turkmen president removes the statue of his predecessor from the city centre

May 9th, 2008

maciula reports on president Berdymukhammedov’s efforts to undo his predecessor’s personality cult (ENG).

Political actualization of free higher education in Kazakhstan

May 9th, 2008

Askhat writes that the religious organization together with the rector of one of the universities are going to organize a press conference and urge for introduction of free higher education in Kazakhstan (KAZ).