Being a Girl in a Post-Soviet State
Culture and History, Uzbekistan13 Comments
Editor’s Note: This article was originally published on Thinking-East in 2005.
Fardona (20, from Uzbekistan) tells us about her life — a life that is not easy, living in a country in which women’s rights are becoming ever more difficult to retain.
Although I am 20 years old and to some of you it may seem that I have little experience, I feel prepared enough to debate and express my opinion on some of the hot topics of today’s Uzbekistan. Most of them are “taboo,” and while they linger in everyone’s mind, they rarely come to the surface within personal accounts.
I want to draw for you a descriptive picture of the present-day situation in my country. I’ll touch upon issues which are a pain in my neck, but I must share them with you. Yet, while negative shades shall dominate my picture, there are so many positive colours that are obscured but are really there. (After all, it is my country.)
Different traditions?
I am originally from the Ferghana Valley, of which most parts are considered to be very “pious.” Though I don’t read the Koran, can’t learn by heart all the holy words said by Our Prophet Muhammad, and don’t usually dress in traditional clothes, I always keep my faith in Allah and know where I belong to-and what my duties are as a Muslim girl.
But apparently, there are different interpretations of what it means to be a Muslim girl.
Some of my friends have stayed in Ferghana due to the prejudice of their parents. Their belief is that it is not appropriate, and even shameful, for a “real” Uzbek girl from a family with a dignified and respectful name to live and study on her own in another city, far away from her home. I overcame these social stereotypes and anachronistic beliefs, deciding to enrol in the University of Tashkent in the capitol of the Republic of Uzbekistan.
As a silent protest against the traditional social fabric that has the “woman’s place” only in the house with her children and chores, I came to a city totally alien to me and started my own life. In Tashkent, I discovered that I wanted to pursue a career, and which path I should follow.
My decisions are tightly connected with the issue of gender equality, which is something immensely contentious in Uzbekistan. Developments during the Soviet period gradually offered women more choices than they ever had before. Today, these gains are becoming ever more difficult to maintain.
Just being a girl
Women’s rights have become so important in human civilisation that they are intricately connected to basic human rights. In contemporary Uzbekistan, the opinion of a woman as well as her wishes and desires are secondary-they come only after those of a man. This is intolerable to girls like me. Hence, we try to become involved in NGOs that work on gender issues and women’s rights.
In truth, there is another reason why I am so concerned about this: my own family. In an allegedly “democratic” and free household, I personally faced violence from my father’s side. …Against which I didn’t fight; I escaped.
Whenever there is a discussion about the role of women in Uzbek society, it’s essentially done to deceive the international community. The creation of new laws and new legal procedures, offering more seats for women in parliament, etc., are parts of a rouse.
Every Uzbek woman expects to be discriminated against due to her marital status, education, social position and so on. When the government tries to involve women in the bureaucracy, even occasionally offering high positions, a woman may simply (and probably) ignore or refuse such opportunities in the fear that she won’t be able to hold onto her gains for a long time. Her family, especially her husband, may disdain her decision to carry this sort of responsibility.
What is this? A matter of religion, gender equality, human rights or just social concerns?
Changing women’s perception
We have already reached the 21st century and the world is changing radically. Yet, it is getting extremely difficult to change women’s attitudes of life, to make them think differently, persuade them how much they can do despite feeling so fragile, to become strong inside themselves.
Thankfully, there are many such girls and women who strive for a better future, who have great expectations from life and are eager to occupy a worthy and dignified place in society and achieve their lives’ goals. I am one of them!
This is due to my mother. Despite her failures with my father, she created a healthy environment for me to continue my education and supported me in my dream of becoming a career woman and attaining financial independence. She made me stand up for my rights and the freedoms she was deprived. Her life was my first teacher! I wish there were more mothers like mine to provide their daughters an opportunity to choose what and when, why and with whom.
This is what girls like me want to change: the ongoing Uzbek social stereotypes that women cannot be a powerful branch in the building of a democratic society in Uzbekistan.
Speaking out
In Uzbekistan, people live with the permanent concern that it is dangerous to get “too” involved in something contentious. Everyone fears getting “warned” for every little criticism made. One example: while researching within the framework of the Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE), my university administration suggested me to change my topic, “Media Freedom in Central Asia,” for my own “sake and security.”
All five Central Asian states are suffering human rights violations in one form or another. There is a ubiquitous lack of freedom of speech, no free and fair elections, and everywhere authoritative governments that are actively preventing any step in the direction of more democratic systems.
Some people even argue that democracy is something which will never be achieved in Central Asia. Despite the region’s fourteen years of independence, there is still a smell of the Soviet period in these countries.
Personally, I sometimes doubt that the idea of “Democracy” is applicable to Central Asian states. If democratization is possible, then it can only be a long-term process, and it will take many years for Central Asia’s nations to cultivate a clear understanding of the necessary principles for a free and open society.
Foreigners in Uzbekistan
An interesting fact is that many foreigners coming to Uzbekistan for the first time always say that Uzbekistan is very “interesting” and a “challenging place to live in.” They tend to stress the country’s sightseeing places, national heritage and our rich and multifarious history, not to speak of the diverse culture and nature.
However, what I would like to hear from these visitors is their real opinions, and maybe even suggestions, recommendations about what could be done better. They see our life from a very different perspective and therefore are likely to be more aware (in some respects) of many things which are still unclear to us, the Uzbek population.
You may say people can obtain the latest updates from local TV, radio or newspapers. Unfortunately, the very sad truth is that none of these news-sources provide us with strong, objective and reliable information on current events in our homeland. You will find no independent media in Uzbekistan besides the Internet (though even then some websites are banned by the government).
You see there are so many questions that remain unanswered for Uzbeks who want to shape the future development of our country and set Uzbekistan free from social stereotypes and dictatorship.
We, the youth, are eager to lead Uzbekistan towards prosperity and establish a real democratic and liberal society, not only for our own sake but also for the sake of future generations.
I am firmly convinced that all threats and problems presently faced by Uzbekistan are a matter that should always be on the agenda of the international community. The world’s part in the future of Uzbekistan is integral.
I would be endlessly happy to know what some of you, my readers, think about my words.




Interesting article. I am due to travel to Tashkent and live there for a period of two years or so. Although I have read many books on Uzbekistan, I think things are as reality always is different in books. So I look forward to exploring this country, city and its people.
Reply
A fascinating insight into the life of a young Uzbek woman. I lived in Uzbekistan for a few years, and I know that a lot of young women feel this. They have no voice. Men speak for them. This is a very honest take on the situation. Thank you, Fardona.
Reply
It is a great article. I have never been to Uzbekistan. But I’m from a post-soviet country as well – Republic of Moldova. The things are very different in my country. We also have home violence, we also have problems with gender issues but they are not so critical. And whenever we have problems, we are waiting for somebody from abroad to solve them. You are trying to do it by ourselfs. So I think the problem in Uzbekistan are more related to the culture, tradition and religion. This problems that you are faicing has nothing to do with Soviet Times. More than that I think you, I mean whole the young generation, are the one who must change things the way you like it. And I’m sure, after reading your ideeas, that you are the right person to do it, you really impresed me with your article.
Reply
I am impressed by your insights. I lived as a foreigner in Uzbekistan for 2 years; several of my students were from Fergana. To want to achieve your best – to have access to many different employment opportunities for you personally and professionally – seems to me to be a universal value that all women should want around the world, regardless of reglion. I know it is often from fear that many mothers don’t want more opportunities for their daughters. And you mentioned that there was a level of violence that you needed to escape. Don’t we all just want a better chance in the world for our children? Don’t we all want our children – male and female- to be strong and capable?
I was so impressed by the people of Uzbekistan- the kindness and the optimism – and I just hope that that optimism for the future can be realised. Your letter shined with all the qualities of the best and strong women I came to know during my 2 years in your country. You are not alone! I wish you the best personally and for growth of opportunities and changes for the better for all the people. Stay brave and strong.
Reply
Yes, you are completely right,
Uzbekistan in terms of policy and economy is shithole
Reply
Excellent article — thank you very much. Young women, such as yourself, will make the world a better place! Use the media and music, collaboration and dialogue to unite with other like-minded young women leaders!
Reply
There is a related post that IMO is quite relevant under this topic here: http://tajikistan.neweurasia.net/?p=163
BTW, I found that Thinking East generally used to have very good articles.
Reply
I agree with Fardona, because I am also feel the same. Great article. Good luck!
Reply
[...] in Muslim countries can be spoken of in a unitary sense, I offer the pause-worthy story of Fardona, a girl from the Ferghana Valley region of Uzbekistan. Don’t forget related thoughts by [...]
Fardona:
Your words haunt me and at the same time give me hope. Ever since visiting Uzbekistan for two weeks in 2005 I have felt truly deep anger toward the Uzbek government and its apparatus — yet harbored such warm feelings toward the general populace. The dignity of the Uzbek people — in spite of the undignified state of their lives — reminds me to look beyond an “us vs. them” mentality when thinking about international relations. I look forward to the day when, through some miraculous shift of events, the sincere goodness shining in you is able to rise to the fore in Uzbek society. In fact, I wish it for all the world, since not only in Uzbekistan is it the case that a cynical and corrupt government rules over a decent citizenry. Please know that many people throughout the world are aware of the true situation in Uzbekistan today; we are not fooled at all by the proclamations of the government in Tashkent.
Reply
Hello everybody, my name is Damion, and I’m glad to join your conmunity,
and wish to assit as far as possible.
Reply
Thank you for giving me an impression with some details of the gender situation in Uzbekistan.
Here in Germany we don’t hear a lot about central asia, it is a part of the world the media rarely focus. When I looked for information in a book store, all they had was a sightseeing book about central asia in general. On the internet I mostly found some very broadsweeping official reports with some statistics.
I am very interested in visiting Uzbekistan and Kyrgizstan when I have the time and get an unvarnished impression, so articles like this help me to get prepared.
Reply
[...] The post also has some great background information on the acting president [...]